The Sound of Si…mon and Garfunkel
Full run through of all collaborative and solo albums from 1964 until now. There was a release in 2002 of their youthful recordings as 'Tom and Jerry', which is an interesting listen, mainly because it shows how many young boys at the time were desperate to jump on the Rock n Roll bandwagon.
Here's the full list of 30 albums that have spanned their careers so far:
Wednesday Morning 3 A.M. (S&G - 1964)
The Paul Simon Songbook (PS- 1965)
Sounds of Silence (S&G - 1966)
Parsley, Sage Rosemary and Thyme (S&G - 1966)
The Graduate (S&G - 1968)
Bookends (S&G - 1968)
Bridge Over Troubled Water (S&G)
Paul Simon (PS - 1972)
There Goes Rhymin' Simon (PS - 1973)
Angel Claire (AG - 1973)
Breakaway (AG - 1975)
Still Crazy After All These Years (PS - 1975)
Watermark (AG - 1977)
Fate For Breakfast (AG - 1979)
One Trick Pony (PS - 1980)
Scissors Cut - (AG - 1981)
Hearts and Bones (PS - 1983)
The Animals Christmas (AG - 1985)
Graceland (PS- 1986)
Lefty (AG - 1988)
The Rhythm of The Saints (PS - 1990)
Songs from a Parent to a Child (AG - 1997)
Songs from the Capeman (PS - 1997)
You're the One (PS - 2000)
Everything Wants to be Noticed (AG - 2002)
Surprise (PS -2006)
So Beautiful or So What (PS - 2011)
Stranger to Stranger (PS - 2016)
In the Blue Light (PS - 2018)
Seven Psalms (PS - 2023)
Released 19th October 1964
WEDNESDAY MORNING 3.A.M. - Simon and Garfunkel
I imagined success came quickly for Simon and Garfunkel. With The Sound Of Silence in their back pocket you'd think the contemprary press would have picked them up quickly. But it doesn't appear to be so. When I looked for reviews of the album in 1964 I found nothing, just a few listings in Billboard, and the tale told on Wikipedia is that it flopped and Simon went off to London to make The Paul Simon Songbook while Garfunkel got his head down on his teaching degree at Columbia University in New York City.
It splits into original songs and covers, which you could further filter into 'Trad. Arr Simon' and the rest. The covers tend toward Christian-folk songs despite them both being of Jewish decent. I listened to the originals (Ed MCurdy's 'Last Night I Had The Strangest Dream' and Bob Gibson's 'You Can Tell The World') and their approach seems to be to play down the guitar gospel side of things and focus on gentler two part harmonies. They also give Dylan's 'The Times They Are A Changin'' a similar treatment. I created a short playlist of original followed by S&G versions. I couldn't find the Ian Campbell Folk Group's original of 'The Sun Is Burning'
They also do 'Go Tell It On The Mountain' which I seem to recall we used to belt out every once in a while in junior school assemblies along with 'Kumbaya' and 'When The Saints Come Marching In'. It was the early seventies, what can I say? They actually adopt quite a different tune to the one I know.
This has the first iteration of 'Sound Of Silence', we're going to get it again on the next two albums in the sequence and it will also turn up on The Graduate soundtrack.This is the "acoustic version" so and it's a little more subdued than later versions. 'Bleecker Street' is a maybe the first of many Simon tributes to New York City. Elsewhere he attempts an original traditional folk song with 'Sparrow'.
There's one song that plays the sore thumb in the tracklist. 'Benedictus' is a monastic chant given the acoustic folk guitar treatment. It's an innovative step too far for me.
You Can Tell the World
Last Night I Had the Strangest Dream
Bleecker Street
Sparrow
Benedictus
The Sound of Silence
He Was My Brother
Peggy-O
Go Tell It on the Mountain
The Sun Is Burning
The Times They Are a-Changin'
Wednesday Morning, 3 A.M.
Released: August 1965
THE PAUL SIMON SONGBOOK - Paul Simon
It's quite hard to gauge the level of well-knownedness of Simon and Garfunkel at this time. The first album doesn't seem to have had much impact but they seem to have gained some traction with Sound Of Silence. For this Simon had been spending time in the UK and this was made in London. Without Art, he's a little harder edged and his Dylan inspired ambitions are more apparent. Also, this is all his own work, as suggested by the album title.
First track is 'I am a Rock', which gives the impression in the way that it's delivered that it's a song of pride and defiance, but as soon as you consider the lyrics it's all loneliness, isolation and coping strategies. It came as a surprise to me when I started to listen to it properly.
'Leaves That Are Green' is notable for it's opening line: "I was 21 years when I wrote this song, I'm 22 now but I won't be for long". Billy Bragg stole it wholesale for 'A New England'. His defence seems to go along the lines of "well it's a good line and I was young". He's right about it being a great line.
As noted above, Sound of Silence comes up a lot on the early albums. It's another one that can be easily misread, especially if you consider the S&G versions, which could be mistaken for a lullaby, rather than a rather grim and despairing urban-religious soundscape. Simon's version here brings out the true meaning more effectively.
There's also a Dylan piss-take. 'A Simple Desultory Phillipic (Or How I Was Robert McNamara'd Into Submission)' Artie gets a name check. Simon gives the impression he thinks his song is a total hoot, but maybe it hasn't aged well. Also he introduces it but replaces "Robert McNamara", with "Lyndon Johnson". This will turn up again on 'Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme'
The rest is the kind of sixties troubadour fare you might expect. Whilst speculating on the artwork with a friend this week it seems it's pulling elements from a couple of songs. There's girlfriend Kathy Chitty and wet cobblestoned streets. We got nowhere with the dolls though.
I Am a Rock
Leaves That Are Green
A Church is Burning
April Come She Will
The Sound of Silence
A Most Peculiar Man
He Was My Brother
Kathy's Song
The Side of a Hill
A Simple Desultory Philippic (Or How I Was Robert McNamara'd into Submission)
Flowers Never Bend With the Rainfall
Patterns
Released 17th January 1966
SOUNDS OF SILENCE - Simon and Garfunkel
The history goes that Sound of Silence was tinkered with without their knowledge (and with their disapproval) and became a hit, so Simon abandoned the UK and they got this out with a certain amount of haste on the record company's orders. It shares 6 of Simon's songs from the Songbook. Of the rest 'Somewhere They Can't Find Me' has more of a pop feel, and the following 'Anji' feels like an instrumental reprise of it.
I learned of the poem Richard Cory by Edward Arlington Robinson through listening to this, The oringial poem describes Cory as a wealthy and admired individual who ends up killing himself. Whilst there is a hint of resentment in the poem for Cory gaining wealth from the poverty of others, Simon and Garfunkel spell it all out a bit more clearly.
Not on here, but released around the same time as a single is 'Homeward Bound', which had to wait until Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme for an album release. It does seem to be important for going hand in hand in contributing to their sudden rise in popularity in early 1966.
Looking shifty on the cover.
The Sound of Silence
Leaves That Are Green
Blessed
Kathy's Song
Somewhere They Can't Find Me
Anji
Richard Cory
A Most Peculiar Man
April Come She Will
We've Got a Groovey Thing Goin'
I Am a Rock
Released: october 24th 1966
PARSLEY, SAGE, ROSEMARY AND THYME
I seriously considered creating a Simon and Garfunkel album Venn diagram and even got an old school stationery set out to try and find a compass. However, the cross fertilization of songs across all their albums is so extensive I doubt it would have been very comprehensible. Still, they have shaken off Sound Of Silence. I would say 'finally', but rest assured it will be back soon. Simon also goes back for another attempt at 'Patterns' and 'Flowers Never Bend with the Rainfall'. He does seem to have a bit of an obsession with the weather comparisons. Rain is a route one song metaphor so if it's cloudy, raining or the cobbled streets are slick with it we know it's probably going to be a downer. Also the risible 'A Simple Desultory Phillipic' gets another bite at the cherry. It's better, but then it couldn't be worse could it?
Wikipedia hedges it's bets on the mythology of Homeward Bound, inserting a doubting 'possibly' into the assertion that it was written on Widnes Station. Well, they've put up a plaque about it there, so that's good enough for me. It's Simon's writing at it's best, heartfelt, touching and meaningful.
'The 59th Street Bridge Song', which surely everyone calls its bracketed subtitle, 'Feeling Groovy' is a featherlight pleasure and features conversations with lampposts.
The title track is Scarborough fair, which I like well enough, but it does feel over-contrived in comparison to the rest of the album. Also, a pronunciation tip. It's Scar-buh-ruh (or even -bruh), not Scar-bo-ro. Same goes for Edinburgh. Frankly I don't care how you say Middlesbrough.
At the end we get Silent Night accompanied by a spoken news report. It's not a genuine clip, but specially made for the song. I can see the point, but it's a little obvious.
I did a trawl through the archives and found a piece from Vogue of June 1967, with picture by Richard Avedon that could well be from the same session as the picture I've used at the the top of the post. Vogue staff wirters were certainly a cut above back then, 'Arthur Garfunkel' has "electrified blond hair and the slouch of spaghetti soft sculpture", while Simon is "round, with black eyes and a Roman fringe"
The packaging suggests that the record company really didn't know how to market them. It looks like a classical album. This approach was more common in the Sixties but it does present them as very 'safe'.
Scarborough Fair/Canticle
Patterns
Cloudy
Homeward Bound
The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine
The 59th Street Bridge Song (Feelin' Groovy)
The Dangling Conversation
Flowers Never Bend with the Rainfall
A Simple Desultory Philippic (Or How I Was Robert McNamara'd into Submission)
For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her
A Poem on the Underground Wall
7 O'Clock News/Silent Night
Released: 21st January 1968
THE GRADUATE - Simon and Garfunkel
I suppose musically this amounts to a review of 'Mrs Robinson'. Everything else has been heard in some form or other before apart from the incidental instrumental pieces by Dave Grusin. I watched the film for the first time and the marrying up of S&G with it doesn't really make sense. Introspective New York folk balladeers for a sex-comedy set in affluent California? Even the specially written song is incongruous, with all its references to Jesus and God. I guess Simon and Garfunkel were recognized as good business at the time.
On the film itself, it's certainly funny. Some bits had me snorting out loud with laughter, but Hoffman and Bancroft are too old and too young respectively, there are just 6 years between them. The brief nudity was completely jarring and unnecessary and much more gratuitous than a lot of stuff that would get the label today. The Robinson's have a bar in their house, which helpfully has a sign stating 'Bar' on it. But, I've watched a lot of films from the late sixties and early seventies recently and it really does feel quite modern. Hoffman deadpans his way through most of it but the crucifix-wielding finale was an unexpected joy.
The Sound of Silence
The Singleman Party Foxtrot
Mrs. Robinson (Version 1)
Sunporch Cha-Cha-Cha
Scarborough Fair/Canticle
On the Strip
April Come She Will
The Folks
Scarborough Fair/Canticle
A Great Effect
The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine
Whew
Mrs. Robinson (Version 2)
The Sound of Silence" (Alternate version)
Released 3rd April 1968
BOOKENDS - Simon and Garfunkel
Sort of half a concept album. Side one has a theme, let's call it The Six Ages Of Man According to Simon and Garfunkel, and then side two are various, largely unrelated additional songs, including Mrs Robinson.
So, the Bookends are birth and death, and there's a 'theme' at the start and end of to bracket the songs within. We go as follows:
'Save The Life Of My Child' - The folly of youth
'America' - Setting out on life's journey to discover yourself and the world
'Overs' - The end, or at least stagnation of relationships
'Old Friends' - Seeing out your final years with memories
There's an unnecessary bit in the middle 'Voices of Old People' which is about a literal a track title as you'll ever find.
These songs are mostly story songs, 'Save The Life Of My Child' is quite jarring. It has passages of quite menacing electronica and operatic backing vocals, but this doomy arrangement fits the outcome of the story. I'm currently listening to 'Miracle and Wonder', a series of interviews with Simon by Malcolm Gladwell and with contributions from other artists. Sting gives his opinion of 'America' and highlights the way the expansiveness of the overall idea of the song is juxtaposed against the small details (buying cigarettes, Mrs Wagner pies, men in gaberdine suits). So that's not my insight, but Mr Sumner's, although it really captures what's so special about the song.
There's a suggestion that side two was somewhat cobbled together just to make up an entire album. It
includes 'Punky's Dilemma', which feels more like a rhyming lyric exercise than anything meaningful (Simon does seem to enjoy just trying things out). 'Mrs. Robinson' was covered on the last album, but I note in addition that it's one of those rarer songs that treats the chorus as the verse and the verses as the chorus. 'Hazy Shade Of Winter' has all kinds of musical surprises in it when you listen carefully. Trumpets to illustrate the Salvation Army band, clarinets behind the guitar melody and enthusiastic tambourine work. Possibly it's better known from the Bangles version, which doesn't deviate much from the original.
Bookends Theme
Save the Life of My Child
America
Overs
Voices of Old People
Old Friends
Bookends Theme
Fakin' It
Punky's Dilemma
Mrs. Robinson
A Hazy Shade of Winter
At the Zoo
Released 26th January 1970
BRIDGE OVER TROUBLED WATER - Simon and Garfunkel
It must have been an instant classic right? Well, I refer you to the Rolling Stone review of 14th May 1970 by one Gregg Mitchell, who was of the opinion that what they had produced really wasn't worth the two year wait and Creedence Clearwater Revival could do better in a quarter of the time. He concedes that the Boxer is their best song yet, but Frank Lloyd Wright is their worst. Here's a link to a blog post with the full text.
https://americansongwriter.com/today-in-bad-music-journalism-part-2-a-review-of-bridge-over-troubled-water-1970/
However, it's not about what Gregg thought about it in 1970, but what I think about it now. It's jam-packed with songs that we all know, even if you don't immediately recognize the titles. Maybe 'Baby Driver's prominence has been enhanced by the movie, but Bridge, Cecilia, The Boxer and Living Boy are part of our cultural DNA.
According to the excellent 'Miracle And Wonder' audiobook, in which Malcolm Gladwell presents extensive interviews with Simon, there are two songs on here which reflect on Art Garfunkel's slow drift away into other interests such as acting. 'So Long Frank Lloyd Wright' and 'The Only Living Boy In New York'. The message in the lyrics of both is fairly clear.
Simon played 'The Boxer' on the first Saturday Night Live after the 9/11 attacks, emphasising the theme of the song as one of determination to come back after a beating (those drums certainly sound like someone slugging away at you). Also, like so many of their songs, it's a New York story.
I'm less keen on Cecilia. Simon likes to experiment with instrumentation and getting percussive effects from unexpected places, but the tapping and banging feels a little overdone on the original studio recording.
'Keep the Customer Satisfied' distracts me because of it's similarity to 'Knock On Wood'. "I get slandered, libelled; I hear words I never heard in the bible" has an identical cadence to "It's like thunder, lightning; The way you love me is frightening"
Back to Gregg, one of his beefs was that they included a cover of 'Bye Bye Love' and that they just lifted EL Condor Pasa and spoiled it even further with 'trite' lyrics. I'm sure that Simon would argue with plentyof justification that the intention was to combine South American and Eurpoean folk traditions into a single saitsfying whole.
From now on, Paul and Artie will be going their separate ways. I have a review of the Concert In Central Park in the archives somewhere, so I may include it here as well, but we'll be hearing from Simon on his own next.
Bridge over Troubled Water
El Cóndor Pasa (If I Could)
Cecilia
Keep the Customer Satisfied
So Long, Frank Lloyd Wright
The Boxer
Baby Driver
The Only Living Boy in New York
Why Don't You Write Me
Bye Bye Love
Song for the Asking
Released 24th January 1972
PAUL SIMON - Paul Simon
First off, there's a line in second track which goes, "My father was a fisherman, my mama was a fisherman's friend". I've done my research and the throat lozenges predate this song by over 100 years. Also Wikipedia offers no further disambiguation on 'Fisherman's Friend' other than the compariatively recently formed Cornish vocal group. So the phrase must have lodged in Simon's brain, probably when he was suffering from a barking cough, while he was spending time in the UK in the previous decade. Anyway, maybe he was unaware, or perhaps it's intentional, but it doesn't half stick out to the British ear at least as a rather corny reference.
But, I get ahead of myself. Without hearing it, does 'Mother and Child Reunion' strike you as a reggae song? Well it is, and it was recorded in Jamaica too. So this is the start of Simon looking for musical inspiration from beyond the standard starting point of American rhythm and blues and European folk music, which is going to culminate in Graceland and The Rhythm Of The Saints. Which is not to say that there isn't plenty of blues-based songs on the album.
Now what is making that noise in the background on 'Me and Julio Down By The Schoolyard'? Is it just Simon doing monkey noises, or is there some kind of treble-wobble-board in use? It's a much more innocent sounding song than the lyirics portray, the light and breezy style and references to the schoolyard makes it sound like a song about friendship, but it's all to do with juvenile delinquency after all.
There's an instrumental too, 'Hobo's Blues' featuring Stephane Grapelli on fiddle and sounding like the backing to a silent movie short.
i found a couple of contemporary reviews, including one by Jon Landau from Rolling Stone. Both seemed keen to compare Simon with John Lennon, who would have released Imagine a few months earlier. It seems they were hoping for some psychological insight from Simon in the way Lennon was laying his soul bare, but were a little disappointed that Simon seemed to be concentrating on producing a well-crafted album of intelligent songs.
Mother and Child Reunion
Duncan
Everything Put Together Falls Apart
Run That Body Down
Armistice Day
Me and Julio Down by the Schoolyard
Peace Like a River
Papa Hobo
Hobo's Blues
Paranoia Blues
Congratulations
Released 22nd May 1973
THERE GOES RHYMIN’ SIMON - Paul Simon
Was he sponsored to write 'Kodachrome'? It's quite odd in that brandnames are rare in popular song names. Off the top of my head I can think of 'Mercedes Benz'. Some quick googling highlights plenty of car brands (and obviously there is a frequent offender here) and reminds me of 'Smells Like Teen Spirit', but 'Kodachrome' is particularly in your face example. But, it's great anyway, a beautifully easy going melody. He follows it with the smooth and lazy 'Tenderness', an appeal for comfort over straight-speaking in a relationship.
In Malcolm Gladwell's Audiobook/Podcast/Interview with Simon, he probes about Simon's Jewish background and whether it manifests in his songwriting. 'Take Me To The Mardi Gras' is put forward with an example from a fanblog (very unreliable in my view) comparing the "toomba, toomba, toomba Mardi Gras" to a Jewish folk song 'Tumbalalaika'. But Simon denies it and says it's influenced by an old New Orleans song. Gladwell is a bit like a dog with a bone with this stuff, so he suggests it's a combination of both explanations, and that maybe Simon had some kind of deep memory that bubbled up.
I fell in love with the slowly tumbling piano, blues and gospel on 'One Man's Ceiling Is Another Man's Floor'. Paul doesn't really want to engage with his neighbours it seems. 'American Tune' has more of a classic S&G feel, rooted in New York, low key and melancholy.
'Loves Me Like A Rock' feels rather like 'Keep The Customer Satisfied' in places, with "rock" references too. Reasonably obscure folk act Rory McLeod did a very similar themed song 'Love Like A Rock (In Stormy Seas)', although musically it's reliant on harmonica and a capella basslines - so it was good to be reminded of that and dig it out of the CD collection.
There is a weird hybrid 60's, 70's and 80's feel about the artwork.
Kodachrome
Tenderness
Take Me to the Mardi Gras
Something So Right
One Man's Ceiling Is Another Man's Floor
American Tune
Was a Sunny Day
Learn How to Fall
St. Judy's Comet
Loves Me Like a Rock
Released 11th September 1973
ANGEL CLARE - Art Garfunkel
Artie's first solo outing and the contemporary review in Rolling Stone suggested he was throwing everything at it, with full orchestrations and any new production techniques available at the time. It is quite lush, but then Garfunkel's singing voice is feather-light, so it can get rathet swamped. Also, Simon was the songwriter and Art is not deluding himself that he can come up with songs of the required calibre, so he has an impressive array of artists and writers whose songs he is singing. There's 'I Shall Sing' by Van Morrison which gets a light calypso treatment and deathbed song 'Old Man' by Randy Newman, which feels Bridge Over Troubled Water-ish. I checked out Newman's version, and while the lyrics remain unchanged, you know that the meaning is very different, where the visiting son is not so much mourning the passing of his father as gloating that he's finally on his way and he'll be top dog instead.
'Down In The Willow Garden' tries to capture some of 'Scarborough Fair's wistfulness and does feature Paul Simon on guitar and vocals, and Garfunkel does steal something of a march on his old partner with
'Woyaya' which doesn't sound very far off what was going on with Graceland 13 years later. There's more trad folk with 'Barbara Allen' too. I found this quite insipid, and I worry that that will be a problem with Garfunkel all the way through. He has a sweet voice, but does he have any range?
Traveling Boy
Down in the Willow Garden
I Shall Sing
Old Man
Feuilles-Oh/Do Space Men Pass Dead Souls on Their Way to the Moon?
All I Know
Mary Was An Only Child
Woyaya
Barbara Allen
Another Lullaby
Released 14th October 1975
BREAKAWAY - Art Garfunkel
"He has a sweet voice, but does he have any range" I said at the end of Angel Clare. Well, it appears he does. This is great. It's still gentle, there's no departure there, but the song choices here are much better than the previous album. The title track is one of those that I instantly recognized while being surprised that it was him, although maybe I'm familiar with the later Gallagher and Lyle version of their own song.
The release of this is almost entirely concurrent with Simon's 'Still Crazy After All These Years' and they even share a song. 'My Little Town', credited to Simon and Garfunkel. I'm assuming it is exactly the same song, i.e. same recording. Obviously it's existence was taken at the time as evidence that Simon and Garfunkel were not yet a spent recording force, but the New York Times at least felt that Simon had moved on to more adult themes on his album while Garfunkel was wallowing in childish sentimentality. 'My Little Town' therefore bucks the trend on Breakaway because sentimental it ain't. ("nothing but the dead and dying back in my little town"). Wikipedia reckons Simon is on "backing vocals", which is a little bit cheeky (or maybe just ignorant) of them.
I think my favourite on this is 'Waters of March', but again, it's more because Artie is a canny chooser of songs to cover. It's a well-covered Brazilian song with a stream-of-consciousness lyric over a soft bossanova. '99 Miles from LA' is a similar success that suits him down to the ground.
He even has a UK number 1 single on this, and we all thought it was just the bunny song that he achieved that with. 'I Only Have Eyes For You' spent two weeks there in October 1975.
So on the strength of this you had to think that Artie had a bright future ahead of him, and he obviously has some hgh points to come, but being a covers artist will only take you so far.
I Believe (When I Fall in Love It Will Be Forever)
Rag Doll
Break Away
Disney Girls
Waters of March
My Little Town
I Only Have Eyes for You
Looking for the Right One
99 Miles from L.A.
The Same Old Tears on a New Background
Released 25th October 1973
STILL CRAZY AFTER ALL THESE YEARS - Paul Simon
Some song titles are ones that their authors must live to regret. '50 Ways To Leave Your Lover' must be one of those, because, of course he does not list 50 ways of chucking someone at all. In fact a generous count comes to 6 ways (if you include "you don't need to discuss much"). For comparison, Rick Astley easily managed to come up with an equal number of ways in which he was never going to leave his lover, and he didn't boast about it in the title. However, it is also the song that lanuched a thousand social media threads wheneve someone asks what the other 44 ways might have been. I like "Sling yer 'ook, Chook".
As noted for the previous Art Grafunkel album, Breakaway released just 11 days earlier, it includes 'My Little Town' as a Simon and Garfunkel song. It's preceded by the title track with a bell-like electric piano intro and wistfulness that lives up to the name of the song. But he does ring the changes from the gentle ballads occasionally 'Gone At Last' brings in a bit of rapid gospel and 'Have A Good Time' is a leisurely blues number. Having said that, I know it's a well-regarded album, but apart from the better known songs I found it a little bit boring? Contemporary reviews felt that it was self indulgent, but then those critics also seemed to be distracted by the presence of My Little Town as a stick to beat him with on how he was better when Artie was about.
I suppose we have to discuss the chapeau, 'tache and chest wig. At first glance he looks like he's in some kind of cage, but it's obviously a New York fire escape.
Still Crazy After All These Years
My Little Town
I Do It for Your Love
50 Ways to Leave Your Lover
Night Game
Gone at Last
Some Folks' Lives Roll Easy
Have a Good Time
You're Kind
Silent Eyes
Released 25th October 1977
WATERMARK - Art Garfunkel
The music on this is unremarkable. It's Art doing what he's really quite good at, which is sweetly singing lightly touching songs. But there is an interesting sub-story in that this is effectively a collaboration with Jimmy Webb, creator of the Wichita Lineman, Galveston and MacArthur Park. Apart from 'What A Wonderful World' and the traditional 'She Moved Through The Fair', these are all his compositions, but if any of them bear comparison to the three mentioned above, it's buried in the lightweight treatment that Artie gives them. There are moments when you can hear something special though, 'Mr Shuck'n'Jive' and 'Paper Chase' have something extra about them.
They toured together too. a contemporary Hollywood Reporter review of their concert at the Dorothy Chandler Pavilion, LA on 17th April 1978 found Art to sing with "the precision of a diamond cutter" while lamenting Webb's lack of "drive and charisma".
As for "(What A) Wonderful World ", it shows that he and Simon couldn't quite shake each other off just yet. It's more of a Simon & Garfunkel & (James) Taylor song than something Art can claim for himself. It's not as good as Sam Cooke, obviously but it does stand out for the quality of the song and the singers.
It received a second relase in January 1978 with '(What A) Wonderful World' replacing 'Fingerpaint', which I suppose tells us that someone considered 'Fingerpaint' to be the weakest track on the original 1977 release. I certainly couldn't find it on Spotify, but it can be heard on YouTube. It's on the more discordant end of the Garfunkel spectrum and they probably made the right decision if they felt they needed to squeeze the hit cover version.
Crying in My Sleep
Marionette
Shine It on Me
Watermark
Saturday Suit
All My Love's Laughter
(What a) Wonderful World
Mr. Shuck'n'Jive
Paper Chase
She Moved Through the Fair
Someone Else (1958)
Fingerpaint
Wooden Planes
Released 15th March 1979
FATE FOR BREAKFAST - Art Garfunkel
What is Cliff Richard's greatest ever song? 'Miss You Nights'. By a country mile. So you would expect Art's cover to be pretty great as well. The song is fairly unbreakable after all. Indeed, it's fine, but that's all and surely we should expect better because he has the voice to pull it off. But somehow it is just not a patch on Cliff's, where the arrangement and delivery are just perfect. In fact the Cliff version always feels like it's almost a Christmas song to me. All that pain and longing coming to a head. When I heard it on this album, I had to go back to the 'original' (it came to Cliff from writer Dave Townsend via Bruce Welch of the Shads) as soon as I heard it.
If you look down the track listing on the Fate For Breakfast page on Spotify each track has a few hundred thousand listens until you get to the 46 million-odd that Bunny Apocalypse song 'Bright Eyes' has achieved (admittedly 'Since I Don't Have You' has clocked up a respectable 4.2M). It was ubiquitous for a while, the biggest selling UK single of 1979. 19 weeks on the chart, 6 at number 1. I assumed that it just pipped 'I Don't Like Mondays' and 'Another Brick In the Wall' (existential angst was big in 1979), but in fact it's nearest challengers were 'YMCA' and that man Cliff again with 'We Don't Talk Any More'.
The remainder is more of Art singing beautifully, but not very interestingly on a series of fairly fogetteable songs, and I fear this will continue, in stark contrast to his erstwhile partner, for some time to come.
In a Little While (I'll Be on My Way)
Since I Don't Have You
And I Know
Sail on a Rainbow
Miss You Nights
Bright Eyes
Finally Found a Reason
Beyond the Tears
Oh How Happy
When Someone Doesn't Want You
Take Me Away
Released 12th August 1980
ONE TRICK PONY - Paul Simon
It's a soundtrack album but at the same time it isn't. Normally I would give serious consideration to watching the accompanying film, and did so with The Graduate, but One Trick Pony seems to have made little impact in popular culture and I'm not sure I want to waste 90 minutes or so on it. It's got Lou Reed too, which puts me off even more. Fortunately the album works perfectly well as a standalone studio effort, so I think I can justify the omission.
'Late In The Evening' is the best known song, a light samba but with some funny popping noises occurring halfway through that sound like modern phone notifications. They turn up again on 'Jonah', it's quite distracting. 'That's Why God Made The Movies' is a subtle blues in a style that Loudon Wainwright III has made his own down the years.
The title track is a live performance, although it's recorded so cleanly that it is quite hard to tell, until the applause at the end. The same is true of the later 'Ace In The Hole' although you can hear the audience clapping along. He's joined by Richard Tee on vocals for this, and his rougher blues vocal is a nice counterpoint to Simon's lighter delivery.
'Long Long Day' is the kind of song that can only appear as the last track on side 2.
It was a struggle to engage with this. It's unmistakeably Paul Simon but doesn't have any grab. even 'Late In The Evening' feels like something to be admired rather than enjoyed.
Late in the Evening
That's Why God Made the Movies
One-Trick Pony
How the Heart Approaches What It Yearns
Oh, Marion
Ace in the Hole
Nobody
Jonah
God Bless the Absentee
Long, Long Day
Released 25th August 1981
SCISSORS CUT - Art Garfunkel
As I trawl through Wikipedia looking for interesting album releases from this week in the past, Art is sighing away in the background. If I might refer back to Simon's last album title, Artie really is becoming a One Trick Pony, sweet gentle songs sung sweetly and gently. This notably opens with Gallagher and Lyle's 'A Heart In New York' which was his only solo contribution to the concert in Central Park, presumably because it is both about New York and sounds like a Simon and Garfunkel song.
The title track is rather good and 'Hang On In' plays like a lightweight Christopher Cross song, if that's possible. Background reading led me to an interview from the Chicago Tribute from September 1981 in which he describes how whereas normally he'd keep going at a song for numerous takes until he was happy, but here he tried to do that less and in the end go for the earlier takes, the idea being that the listener gets a sense of a more spontaneious approach. I think it probably takes a keener ear than mine to detect any significant difference, but I guess the overall sound does come out as more engaging.
Bright Eyes gets a reprise. It wasn't released on the US version of Fate for Breakfast, so that omission is corrected here. The UK version had 'The Romance' instead, of which there is no trace on Spotify.
Art's album artwork is a real weak point (although Simon hasn't been much better so far), this is very much the artist as serious musician in that he looks like he might be 3rd viola in the New York Philharmonic.
A Heart in New York
Scissors Cut
Up in the World
Hang On In
So Easy to Begin
Bright Eyes
Can't Turn My Heart Away
The French Waltz
In Cars
That's All I've Got to Say (Theme from The Last Unicorn)
Released November 4th 1983
HEARTS AND BONES - Paul Simon
Possibly moving into Simon's true golden period now. Lots of artists seem to enter into a run of about three exceptional albums. In the case of Simon, this feels like preparatory sketches for Graceland and then he over-egged it a little on The Rhythm of the Saints.
This came off the back of the reunion with Garfunkel in Central Park and was meant to be a new S&G album, but the story goes that Simon felt the songs were too personal and cut Artie out, thus putting the kibosh on any possibility of a future collaboration.
There's two 'versions' of 'Think Too Much', but they're pretty much just different songs. (b), which confusingly comes first has the light calypso backing whereas (a) is more of a funk-rock affair, with lots of hard-to-fathom sound effects. I want to say one of them might be a telex machine?? The reason for the repetition is that the theme of the album is the conflict of heart and head, and Simon obviously feels he is ruled by pragmatism.
Train In The Distance provides the clearest future echoes of Graceland, but I think the following two songs, 'Rene and Georgette Magritte with Their Dog After The War' and 'Cars are Cars' are the standouts on the album for me. 'Rene...' is a kind of perfect musical portrait of the subject matter. Although it sounds like it should be based on a painting, it's a couple of photographs that gives the song its name. 'Cars are Cars' is a Talking Heads-y piece which again juxtaposes the practicality of a reltionship with a machine with the complexity of dealing with people and emotions.
That's some shirt and tie combo.
Allergies
Hearts and Bones
When Numbers Get Serious
Think Too Much (b)
Song About the Moon
Think Too Much (a)
Train in the Distance
René and Georgette Magritte with Their Dog after the War
Cars Are Cars
The Late Great Johnny Ace
Released October 1986
THE ANIMALS CHRISTMAS - Art Garfunkel
The worst time to listen to a Christmas album is probably at the end of February, but this is what the fates have dealt us. It's also not quite what I was expecting, since it's essentially a classical cantata for soloists and choir. It comes on like Orff's O Fortuna at the very beginning but soon settles down into something very festive and beautiful. Garfunkel and Grant have the right kind of voices for this mildly devotional stuff. He's the narrator/Gabriel and she's Mary. They've got the King's College School Choir and the London Symphony Orchestra on board so there's no skimping on the quality.
On his website there's a short interview piece in which he describes how it served as a break from the commercialism of his usual work in the music business. He was probably smarting a bit from the collapse of any long term prospect of new success with Simon, but it does seem to be a heartfelt project that makes him proud.
The Annunciation
The Creatures of the Field
Just a Simple Little Tune
The Decree
Incredible Phat
The Friendly Beasts
The Song of the Camels
Word from an Old Spanish Carol
Carol of the Birds
The Frog
Herod
Wild Geese
Released 25th August 1986
GRACELAND - Paul Simon
Summer 1986 and there's a TV show going out on BBC2 aimed pretty much at people of my age, No Limits. A sort of British travelogue/music show presented by chirpy young folks occupying the TV music landscape somewhere between Top Of The Pops and The Tube. I don't remember much of it now, but the premiere of the 'You Can Call Me Al' video on it was a standout moment. Woo, look! It's got Chevy Chase in it and they're larking about a lot. It just feels like a funny song too, slightly surreal with its references to being "soft in the middle" and escaping down alleyways with roly poly little bat-faced girls. For someone of my age (we're talking 18-19 here) it introduced Simon as something quite different from the 50% of S&G that he'd been (in my perception) up till then.
Of course this is a massively important (and successful) record, because of how and where it was recorded against the background of the anti-apartheid movement, which was all consuming as the issue of the day if you were a young idealist. To be honest, I probably wasn't that idealistic in that sense at the time, conservative influences in my upbringing meant my knowledge of South African politics was superficial at best. Simon was accused of breaking the cultural boycott by recording with South African artists, never mind that these were largely black South African artists and the album did more to broaden the cultural understanding of their music. The songs aren't about apartheid, which was another problem for his critics. I think we've learned a lot in the intervening 35 years and making culture visible and accessible can generally be seen as a good thing, even if you disapprove of the government and policies under which the art is created. I guess there's a 'white saviour' aspect that can be levelled at Simon too, but if he wasn't going to do it, who was?
But the interweaving of the South African sounds and voices is pure genius. This is a modern pop record, with great tunes and hooks but with a soundscape different from anything that had been in the mainstream before. Maybe the most beautiful part is the sequence of 'Under African Skies' with Linda Ronstadt perfectly complementing Simon on backing vocals, which is then followed by the a capella collaboration with Ladysmith Black Mambazo on 'Homeless'.
This is the textbook definition of a classic album, it's timeless and familiar as old shoes. It also takes me back to those early student years again. This was heard regularly in the hovel and I even recall a very drunken rendition of The Boy In The Bubble in the grease-smeared kitchen one evening.
The Boy in the Bubble
Graceland
I Know What I Know
Gumboots
Diamonds on the Soles of Her Shoes
You Can Call Me Al
Under African Skies
Homeless
Crazy Love, Vol. II
That Was Your Mother
All Around the World or the Myth of Fingerprints
Released 29th March 1988
LEFTY - Art Garfunkel
At first it seems that Artie has gone the full Chicago. 'This Is The Moment' is the kind of dull, plodding, vacant song that any number of AOR artists were churning out about 10 years earlier, but his redeeming quality is that he relies on others to write his songs. so there isn't really an Art Garfunkel style rut that he can get stuck in. Most of this is gently catchy pop songs with a few interesting twists, such as the harmonies on 'So Much In Love' and the lightly bouncing rythm on 'King Of Tonga'
His take on 'When A Man Loves A Woman' owes nothing to Percy Sledge, nor indeed, Michael Bolton. It's a murmured, introspective interpretation including what sounds like birdsong (probably from a synth) and really quite beautiful. But on the whole, this is pleasant but unremarkable stuff. I can't believe anyone holds it in a cherished place in their heart, including Garfunkel.
This Is the Moment
I Have a Love
So Much in Love
Slow Breakup
Love Is the Only Chain
When a Man Loves a Woman
I Wonder Why
King of Tonga
If Love Takes You Away
The Promise
Released October 16th 1990
THE RHYTHM OF THE SAINTS - Paul Simon
Advance publicity seemed to suggest that we were getting Graceland II - The New World and Simon had traded in African rhythms for South American drums. In the end we seemed to get Graceland 1.5, a sort of sequel but not quite, and, in my view just not as good. I've listened to this down the years and I've never really engaged with it at all. Even with 4 or 5 listens in recent weeks, I still have no compulsion to go back to it. It may be that there just isn't enough material here which grabs the listener. It starts so strongly with 'The Obvious Child' and rallies a little with 'Born At The Right Time' but I find the rest really forgettable. Even 'Born at the Right Time' sounds like it belongs on its predecessor. It feels like he wanted to recreate the Graceland experience with a different type of music, but got held back by also wanting to retain some of the things that worked before. Maybe the record company meddled and so the end result was diluted. No-one was expecting pan pipes and llamas but there is no sense of place on The Rhythm of the Saints.
On the plus side, this now feels like catharsis. I've finally admitted I don't like it much even though I invested money in it all those years ago.
The Obvious Child
Can't Run But
The Coast
Proof
Further to Fly
She Moves On
Born at the Right Time
The Cool, Cool River
Spirit Voices
The Rhythm of the Saints
Released 7th June 1997
SONGS FROM A PARENT TO A CHILD - Art Garfunkel
Sort of a children's album, well absolutely a children's album really, but the songs are not so much children's songs as those at the lightest, most harmless end of the pop spectrum. So we get 'Morning Has Broken' which was repurposed as an assembly hymn when I was a child along with 'Michael Row The Boat Ashore', 'Kumbaya' and 'Turn Turn Turn'. We still stuck with some traditional C of E fare mind you, 'Jerusalem', 'There is a Green Hill Far Away' and 'To Be A Pilgrim' were all on heavy rotation in the assembly hall of Flax Hill junior school.
Art goes for John Sebastian's 'Daydream', James Taylor's 'Secret O Life' and Lennon and McCartney's 'I Will' as well. This last is presumably subject to some kind of copyright protection as it is not part of the album on streaming services. 7 year old son James gives a charming performance of 'Good Luck Charm', like Little Jimmy Osmond without any commercial considerations. He finishes up with The Lord's Prayer (fine) and then 'Now I Lay Me Down To Sleep', which I always find quite creepy, with its threat of sudden death in the night. maybe I listen to too much Metallica. Art avoids anything beyond the first two lines.
No-one can possibly object to this. It's objectively lovely and to criticize would be like kicking a puppy. Neither Simon or Garfunkel had put out any new studio material for 7 years and it seems that for Art at least, this was because he was connecting with his new young family, culminating in this album.
Who's Gonna Shoe Your Pretty Little Feet?
Morning Has Broken
Daydream
Baby Mine
Secret O' Life
The Things We've Handed Down
You're A Wonderful One
Good Luck Charm
I Will
Lasso The Moon
Dreamland
Who's Gonna Shoe Your Pretty Little Feet? (Reprise)
The Lord's Prayer / Now I Lay Me Down to Sleep
Released 18th November 1997
SONGS FROM THE CAPEMAN - Paul Simon
For his first and last attempt at a musical, Simon opts for a story set in the fifties about New York Puerto Rican street gangs in conflict with Irish-American rivals and ending in tragedy. Can't go wrong right? Well maybe the superficial similarities to another prominent work distracted the Broadway critics, but like it they did not and it closed after 8 weeks. There's a documentary on YouTube which gives the creative team's side of the story, but it was clearly a very troubled production as Simon worked his way through 4 directors before it got to the stage.
It's hard with musical soundtracks to get a feeling for the overall artistic outcome. You wouldn't listen to the soundtrack of many musicals and get a good idea of the story from the songs alone. It's easy to be glib (my default setting) about the setting and themes but this is very different from Bernstein's work. It's based on the true story of the killing of two boys by members of the Puerto Rican 'Vampires' gang when they mistook their victims for rival 'Norsemen'. In particular it focuses on Salvador Agron, 'The Capeman', so called because he wore a red lined black cape on the night in question. There was also 'The Umbrella Man', gang leader Tony Hernandez, who used a sharpened umbrella as a weapon. How very James Bond. Agron was convicted and sentenced to death at age 16, but the sentence was eventually reduced and he was eventually released and somewhat made amends for his crimes in later life. The problem suggested by the documentary is that Broadway critics simply didn't like the way Simon and his team went about staging the play.
As for the songs, they are quite sweary, which comes as a shock when you consider his previous work, but they are also very engaging, mostly in a doo-wop and latin style. As an album in it's own right, freed of the constraints of supporting a dramatic performance it stands up really well.
Adios Hermanos
Born in Puerto Rico
Satin Summer Nights
Bernadette
The Vampires
Quality
Can I Forgive Him
Sunday Afternoon
Killer Wants to Go to College
Time Is an Ocean
Virgil
Killer Wants to Go to College II
Trailways Bus
Released 3rd October 2000
YOU’RE THE ONE - Paul SImon
When reading the full blog post you get no sense of how quickly I went through all the albums. If you pay any attention to the drip, drip onto social media, album by album, then you'll know that I have hardly listened to any of S&G's output over the summer of 2023. The nature of this album may be partially to blame as it hasn't inspired much of anything in me. Simon creates beautiful, measured songs as usual, but it amounts to a continuation of the furrow ploughed by Graceland and The Rhythm of the Saints. Having siad that, second track 'Darling Lorraine' is a fine example of him at his best and something that would sit easily amongst his best latter day work (i.e. Graceland and Rhythm...).
He's reflective about his advancing years, he would have been approaching 60 at the time of the album but puts it in perpective in 'Old' by placing in context of the life of the universe. Overall though this feels like he's marking time and keeping it safely within his comfort zone. The experience with Capeman reputedly hit him hard, so maybe he produced this from the safety of the shell he'd retreated into, just to confirm that he still had it.
That's Where I Belong
Darling Lorraine
Old
You're the One
The Teacher
Look at That
Señorita with a Necklace of Tears
Love
Pigs, Sheep and Wolves
Hurricane Eye
Quiet
Released 8th October 2002
EVERYTHING WAITS TO BE NOTICED - Art Garfunkel
Wikipedia states that this is "Garfunkel's debut as a songwriter", but that can't be right can it? I'm not prepared to trawl through all the albums looking for a writing credit, but he must have some kind of co-authorship sonewhere surely?
Whatever the case, he should have tried his hand at it earlier, this is a much more engaging album than nearly all of his post S&G work. It's a collaboration with two other singer-songwriters, Maia Sharp and Buddy Mondlock, and it seems that Artie's best work does come along when he's in partnership. There's less reliance on the sweetness of his voice, which is instead blended nicely with his partners, and more on interestingly complex arrangements. They even go a little Beach Boys on 'Turn Don't Turn Away'. Much of it is kind of like what Simon and Garfunkel would have come up with if they'd done a Country and Western album. Garth Brooks is co-credited with one song, 'Every Now and Then'.
Bounce
The Thread
The Kid
Crossing Lines
Everything Waits to Be Noticed
Young and Free
Perfect Moment
Turn, Don't Turn Away
Wishbone
How Did You Know?
What I Love About Rain
Every Now and Then
Another Only One
Released 9th May 2006
SURPRISE - Paul Simon
If you felt inclined to do so, you might consider listening to Harry Styles' Music for a Sushi Restaurant and Sure Don't Feel In Love from this album in quick succession. I'm making no suggestion of plagiarism here, they are very distinct songs, but to grab a passing cliche, you could conclude that they share a little DNA. There's a light quirkiness about them both, especially in the use of falsetto. My only real conclusion from this is that Styles is a much better singer and songwriter than your average music snob might give him credit for, and in this case at least, he is holding his own against arguably the master.
Indeed, this does feel like a master at work, meaningful, well constructed but catchy songs. Brian Eno is involed in three tracks including 'Another Galaxy', which is a standout. Thereis also a sort of forgotten Paul Simon classic in 'Father and Daughter' which reached a modest number 31 in the UK. Considering it was tied in to The Wild Thornberrys Movie it's remarkably touching and personal. It has echoes of some of that minor-key African guitar from Graceland.
How Can You Live in the Northeast?
Everything About It Is a Love Song
Outrageous
Sure Don't Feel Like Love
Wartime Prayers
Beautiful
I Don't Believe
Another Galaxy
Once Upon a Time There Was an Ocean
That's Me
Father and Daughter
Released 8th April 2011
SO BEAUTIFUL OR SO WHAT - Paul Simon
I haven't dragged this out for so long just so I could experience Paul Simon's Christmas song at the appropriate time of year, but here I am on 20th December 2023 and 'Getting Ready for Christmas Day' is opening up this, his 12th solo album and with only two more to go. It's not all that festive in feel to be honest, so it's no wonder it hasn't caught on as a companion to 'Simply having...', 'Step Into Christmas' and 'Merry Xmas (War is Over)' on every Christmas compilation album ever made. In fact it's got more of a Sheryl Crow feel, that circulating acoustic guitar thing.
Just a couple of songs later and Simon is well back into the 'World Music' groove with 'Dazzling Blue' that starts with some clear Carnatic music and dance influences. It's another successful merging of his own songwriting style and a traditional music, but you could borrow one of his previous album titles and suggest he's now become a bit of a one-trick pony, within the confines of creating smooth, contemplative songs over an ethnic beat.
Ultimately it's yet another nice Paul Simon album, with lots of good Paul Simon songs on it, but that's all. It's redeemed by the final, title track, in which we find his philosophy of life has become a shrug of "do what makes you happy". Easy for him to say as the royalty cheques from Bridge Over Troubled Water continue to roll in.
Getting Ready for Christmas Day
The Afterlife
Dazzling Blue
Rewrite
Love and Hard Times
Love Is Eternal Sacred Light
Amulet
Questions for the Angels
Love and Blessings
So Beautiful or So What
Released 3rd June 2016
STRANGER TO STRANGER - Paul SImon
When Warren Zevon created Werewolves of London, he provided the howls from his own body. Simon somehow manages to do it with a guitar, although he does add in some canine impressions of his own too on 'The Werewolf'. In his later albums there has tended to be sufficient residual interest in what he is doing to have one somg that breaks through onto radio. In this case it's 'Wristband', about being denied entry to his own concert because he doesn't have the requisite arm accessory. Both of these songs are collaborations with Clap! Clap!, an Italian dance outfit, but I'm not sure you'd know it without being told. Simon has always had a good ear for a catchy beat and both of these seem like natural, unaided Simon songs.
The album is front-loaded with these collaborations, the third being 'Street Angel', which does have more of a sample-y, fragmented feel to it. It comes after 'The Clock', just over 1 minute of a ticking clock accompanied by some minimalist instrumentation.
The title track appears to be all about getting to the heart of how and why he writes songs combined with the age-old question, if we met each other today, would we still fall in love? Probably not I guess. Lives would have taken a different path and different people would have come our way. It's like asking if we'd met when we were younger, would we have had more time? Nope, we'd probably not be ready for each other yet.
There's an instrumental tribute to his wife, Edie Brickell with 'In The Garden of Edie' and he tackles the loss of a young soldier in 'The Riverbank', asking questions about whether he pursued a military career to find another family from the one that ends up grieving him by the river.
Ed Sheeran did a song called 'Insomniac's Lullaby' too. One year after this one. He has a reputation as an alleged plagiarist.
There's some terrific tuba work on 'Cool Papa Bell' and marimbas scattered all over the album and that bright African guitar still holds strong all these years after Graceland. It's a nice album, involving and showing that Simon still has plenty to say. Pretty good artwork too.
The Werewolf
Wristband
The Clock
Street Angel
Stranger to Stranger
In a Parade
Proof of Love
In the Garden of Edie
The Riverbank
Cool Papa Bell
Insomniac's Lullaby
Released 7th September 2018
IN THE BLUE LIGHT - Paul Simon
In what feels like a very generous gesture by Paul Simon in the context of this blog post, his final studio album to date is actually a compilation of re-recordings of some lesser known songs from his back catalogue. It means I can look back and see if any of these songs siezed my attention first time around. He does lean heavily on You're The One mind you, 4 of the 10 tracks come from there.
So 'One Man's Ceiling Is Another Man's Floor' from Rhymin' Simon is just as good. He retains the piano, how could he not? I was quite ambivalent about 2000's You're The One, blaming a lack of adventure on the Capeman disaster, and to be honest, 'Love' from that album is still no more than a pleasant song. 'Can't Run But' feels rather more stripped down than the original from Rhythm of the Saints with little more than a string quartet for instrumentation.
I didn't mention 'How The Heart Approaches What It Yearns' on the One Trick Pony piece. It provides this album's title but it remains unremarkable to me, in so much as he churns out anything, he churns out this kind of thing quite regularly.
I'm not sure why I missed 'Pig Sheep and Wolf' from You're The One, a quirky metaphorical tale of how a pack of wolves get the blame for killing a sheep when it was the pig wot done it.
'Renee and Georgette Magritte with their Dog After the War' is just as good as the Hearts and Bones version and it's followed by two more from You're the One, 'The Teacher' and the standout for me from that album, 'Darling Lorraine', which seems to have acquired some animal noises? Maybe he felt that the songs on that album didn't get the treatment they deserved, which is why they make up so much of this one.
'Some Folks Lives Roll Easy' was on Still Crazy..., buried on side 2. It's an odd little song really, made odder by the jazz arrangement here in place of the more countrified original. He then finishes with the relatively recent 'Questions for the Angels from So Beautiful or So What.
One Man's Ceiling Is Another Man's Floor
Love
Can't Run But
How the Heart Approaches What It Yearns
Pigs, Sheep and Wolves
René and Georgette Magritte with Their Dog After the War
The Teacher
Darling Lorraine
Some Folks' Lives Roll Easy
Questions for the Angels
Released 19th May 2023
SEVEN PSALMS - Paul Simon
It turns out Simon sneaked out another offering this year, which I had not accounted for. Seven Psalms seems to be just that, Simon's attempt to create seven pieces of music in the style of the biblical psalms. It's all acoustic and Spotify actually presents it as a single 33 minute track.
Here's my take on the lessons he is presenting to us...
'The Lord' seems to be a meditation on what we, or Paul Simon at least can conceive of as God from the benign virgin forest to the destructive forces of COVID and oncoming environmental doom. This serves as a refrain throughout the rest of the piece.
His reflection on love with 'Love Is Like a Braid', represents it as both an entanglement and harmony and beauty entwined. The duality of love is also compared to the rose and the thorn, if you have both then the damage that the thorn makes must be mended.
'My Professional Opinion' is s conversation with himself, your opinion of yourself sort of has to be a professional one, you are your own life's work after all. His conclusion is that there isn't much point being miserable, let the tensions and bad feelings go. Oh, and yo can blame God for them too.
In 'Your Forgiveness' is a little too oblique for me to really get a sense of meaning. It's certainly abut forgiveness, but is it being asked of God at the point of death (the "white light" after "2 billion hearbeats").
'Trail of Volcanoes' raises some serious questions about how Simon views his legacy, certainly from the early days. His journeys now look like a "trail of volcanoes exploding with refugees". Is he sick of being asked about meaning? He seems to regret that any past misinterpretation cannot now be fixed.
'The Sacred Harp' is a tale of picking up a mother and son on the road who seem to be either on the run from their past or simply on a constant journey. The boy is selectively mute suggesting underlying anxiety with his situation.
More death with the final 'Wait'. He fears his 'dark intuition' about what is coming by hopes for 'a dreamless transtion'.
A couple of reviewers have compared this to Bowie's Blackstar due to the themes of reflection on impending death. Simon is still here at time of writing, so let's hope this is more of an artistic exercise than anything more concerning
The Lord
Love Is Like a Braid
My Professional Opinion
Your Forgiveness
Trail of Volcanoes
The Sacred Harp
Wait